Friday, October 5, 2012

Paper for Artepolis 4



NETWORK MECHANISM IN TRADITIONAL HUMAN SETTLEMENT IN ASIA (Cases: Nagari in Minangkabau, Indonesia and Tara in Malabar, Kerala, India)
2012: Paper presented for Arte-Polis4 on Bandung, 5-7 July 2012 held by ITB,,Bandung, Indonesia

Abstract
This paper tried to elaborate the concept of network and connectivity of two settlement concepts of matrilineal society: Nagari in Minangkabau, Indonesia and Tara in Malabar in Kerala, South India. In this concept of settlement network and connectivity are central mechanism and process that build the unity of habitation referred to integrative notion of maternal ancestress, regardless the  spread spatial distribution of the settlement components. Adding to it, the economic expansion also attach on this concept, proved by situations that both ethnic of Minangkabau and Kerala are known as entrepreneuring ethnic.
This topic is brought as a critical review on architectural discourse about traditional settlements, which often describe it as static, obsolete and therefore irrelevant topic to contemporary situation, This architectural description often contradicts the ethnographic descriptions where the pre-Colonial and traditional settlement of Asia had been also described as dynamic and enterprising, comparable to modern situations in manner of network and connectivity.
Realizing the difficulty to elaborate the dynamic situations concepts of the traditional settlement this paper would use the term coined by Egenter (1997) - settlement-architecture. Settlement-architecture defines habitation not as a static unity configured by settlement component. It is a controlled territory composed by elements of a horizontal network of landscape which maintained network equilibrium with other habitation units in an indefinite extent. In this framework kinship, maternal ancestor would be exposed to explain the development of network and connectivity that build up a habitation with which the economic flows manifest though its spatial interconnections.

Saturday, April 7, 2012

Guest Lecture



Saturday, March 31, 2012

Phenomenon of District Art in Kala Godha Festival, Mumbai


This paper is a descriptive discourse that try to uphold the globally growing discourse of creative society in urban area where urban space, is functionally discussed more than engineered physical object. Street, district,
landmark contain more than cognitive and artistic value as conventionally understood. It molds multi-facet social relations between space and people as stake holders and participants, simultaneously or specifically for artistic,
social, religious and cultural motive. The events of Kala Godha festival is a case where urban space articulate participative and holistic designed object and in return contribute to the shaping of identity, place-making as well as awareness for environmental preservation.

Saturday, November 19, 2011

Vernacular Houses in Thazhathangadi Theruvu, Kottayam, Kerala, India

Jurnal, Tesa Arsitektur - Journal of Architectural Discourse, Volume 9, No.1, June 2011, ISSN1410-6094


Abstract
This article is written based on an observation on vernacular residential architecture in Thazhathangadi Theruvu, Kottayam, Kerala, and South India. The approach of study is descriptive approach, done by field documentation and interaction with the owners.  The result demonstrates that houses in Thazhathangadi Theruvu had concept of granary-house. The granary-house concept appears as a core-hall structure that contains set of storage structure ara-nilavara and pattaram. From this core-hall further extension to develop more elaborate dwelling space starts. The structural extension of a residential building generally develops in concentric order around the core-hall and or connecting it to annex buildings.   People, regardless community and caste, considers this core-hall with full respect.

Keywords: vernacular house, granary, granary-house, ara, veedu, nira, nilavara, ekasala, Kerala

Sunday, December 19, 2010

A Study of Typology of Vernacular Residential Architecture in Kerala

Title Article for

International Convention of Asia Scholars (ICAS 5),2007, Kuala Lumpur


Abstract

Traditional-vernacular architecture of Kerala is an exceptional South-Indian artistic typology, found nowhere else in India, and interestingly shared artistic commonality with traditional architecture in Southeast Asia. In this case, author use sample of architectures in Sumatran, Indonesia as typological comparison. Tropical climate, living culture based on wet-paddy agriculture, matrilineal kinship, and history of maritime trading, had contributed shared characteristic to both regional outlook of the architecture. Aspects of Southeast Asian Architecture, rendered by Roxana Waterson (1988), Gaudenz Domenig (1980); and Jacques Dumarcay (1988) are in many respects applicable to verify traditional-vernacular architecture of Kerala, by marking: hipped and gabled roof running steep- closed to typical of Dongson's art; significance of granary and its development into residential shelter, wood construction, and the organic settlement's arrangements. Typical of courtyard house (nalukettu) in Kerala may be the only mainstream characters of Indian architecture that marks discontinuity of Kerala architecture's vocabulary with the Southeast Asian architecture. For case of Kerala's architecture, possible background suggested to lend base on the shared characters are: first, the cultural seclusion of Kerala from the rest of Indian sub-continent until first century AD, due to natural boundary of Western Ghatz. This had held progressive Aryanization to deep South-India until the approximate reign of Indianization in Southeast Asia. Second: the development of maritime trading with overseas countries played important role in the establishment of the culture, including contact with Austronesian and Austro-Asian culture. Coedes (1964) has underlined that remnant of the Austro-Asiatic and Austronesian culture was observable by marking existence of social tradition based on canal settlement, wet paddy farming tradition and irrigation, with matrilineal kinship, as well as the importance of coastal community. (Coedes, 1967; Hornell, 1920). These characters are found in traditional-vernacular domestic living culture and residential architecture of Kerala. This paper is a discursive attempt to respond on narration of Asian architecture as formatted mostly based on high-traditional architectural artifacts (palaces, religious buildings), and is directed to mainly mark distinctions among Asian cultures. This paper also responds on mainstream viewpoint about South Indian culture which is tended to be mainly explained as affiliated with culture of Central Asia, Mediterranean and Arya. Realm of vernacular architecture study on the other hand shall show how in the operating day-to-day art and craft, the commonality with Southeast Asian culture is more obvious. Before 1960's field of vernacular architecture (architecture of the commoners) such as house were considered negligible to signify cultural importance. But currently it is realized that vernacular art reflect more indigenous, less historical, less political and more spontaneous living culture than High-Traditional architecture, so as to be able to represent more natural development of a indigenous living culture. Observing case of traditional residential architecture of Kerala and Sumatra, we hopefully learn that it seems obvious that part of Southeast Asian and part of South Asian architecture might have once belonged to a global and homogeneous tradition, regardless current modern but unraveling, different geo-political boundaries. Hypothetically, traditional architecture's style of Kerala when is compared with Southeast Asian traditional architecture potentially make obvious a sustaining shared typology of the indigenous structure of Asian domestic living architecture.

A Comparative Study of Vernacular Settlement and Dwelling Culture: A Case Study in Kerala, South India, and Minangkabau in Sumatra, Indonesia

Title Article for

International Journal of Interdisciplinary Social Sciences, Volume 4, Issue 2, pp.15-30. Article: Print (Spiral Bound). Article: Electronic (PDF File; 1.527MB).

By Indah Widiastuti and Ranee Vedamuthu.

Abstract

This paper discusses several aspects of vernacular settlements in Kerala and Minangkabau. The framework for the study is architecture as part of holistic system of landscape. The inquiry is directed to explore simultaneous correlation between social organization, settlement configuration and the architecture of ancestral house in both regions of Kerala and Minangkabau. The comparative study is directed to elaborate the aspects of agreement and difference by which contextual conditions underlining the design could be identified. In general both vernacular settlement organization in Kerala and Minangkabau acknowledge the concept of network of villages, called Nagari in Minangkabau and Tara in Kerala. The activities of settlement are generated by the corporate house-hold unit managed under matrilineal descent-group, or Saparauik in Minangkabau and Taravad in Kerala, which is institutionalized architecturally in ancestral maternal house, or Rumah Gadang in Minangkabau and courtyard house in Kerala (naluketttu, ettukettu or Patinjarukettu). Several maternal-ancestral houses were traditionally organized in communal assembly of male-head care-takers in settlement level which is called kuttam in Kerala and Ninik- mamak in Minangkabau. Originally the organization was clan-based but following the length of a historical process, it underwent contextual transformations, and therefore made distinctions. The topic is expected to raise a discourse about a subtle transitional difference between Indian and Indonesian culture. The discourse would provide base for a critical review on geopolitical-based scholarly classification in the traditional and vernacular architecture studies in general, such as Southeast Asian architecture and Indian architecture, and on discourse of cultural diffusion such as “Indianized Southeast Asia”. This topic of this paper would emphasize the importance of settlements formation as factors that define architecture and its theoretical classifications. Theme 2: Interdisciplinary Social Science Practices Of human life-ways: anthropology in its contexts.

Keywords: Settlement, Architecture, Tara, Nagari, Dwelling-culture, Vernacular, Minangkabau, Kerala, Matriliny